The horse IS before the cart.
If people are going to invest their money in advancing paintball to a spectator sport, they're only going to do so with certain things in place to give them a reasonable expectation of making their money back.
Players are free to come up with their own millions of dollars to pull this off, and then they can decide to play whatever they want. Of course, as soon as it iss THEIR $250k on the line, they wouldn't want to be giving their product away to other leagues either. "Ok, guys, we just each spent $250k to create our own pro league. Now lets go pay someone else and play there."
You can't have your cake and eat it too. You're right - paintball isn't a spectator funded sport yet - but if the restrictions arn't there, it never will be, because spectators could just go to a different event and watch the same players and teams for free, thus undercutting the other league's attempt to become profitable.
And the deal is obviously worthwhile to the players, or they wouldn't be taking it. They can be a Pro player in NXL, or not. Their call. I really don't see how them bitching about the terms of their employment is any different from the rest of us bitching about the terms of ours. Everybody WANTS more, but that doesn't mean it's reasonable to expect it.
Anyway, you guys have lots of "It's better for me if it's this way" and 'It's not nice' reasons, but you've got zero economic reasons to allow players to play elsewhere, and those are really the only reasons that count. Until someone can tell the NXL et. al. why NXL players being able to play elsewhere is going to help the NXL league be successful, it ain't going to happen.
Of course, one way would be for all the pro players to collectively refuse to play the NXL under the current conditions - but I don't think the players really care that much, nor am I terribly sure the NXL really cares that much if they have to go to other players who ARE willing to play under their conditions, so that might not work. And if it wouldn't, that just illustrates the economic reality of the situation. Free enterprise does a nice job of giving people what they're actually worth as opposed to what they think they should get.
- Chris