Now that I'm back from Miami and caught up at work, I finally have time to catch up on here. After reading this whole thread (and skipping most of Raehl's drivel
), I just have a couple of comments. I'm responding to a lot of previous posts, so this might get a little long....
re: reffing bias
A couple of people have mentioned the need for an impartial reffing group and I agree with that. However, I think the current NPPL reffing group is about as impartial as you're going to get. As an NPPL ref, I know the guys who work these events and I don't know of any who have industry ties. They work at fields, they play at the local level, some even played at the national level. But none of them are in the pocket of any major team, sponsor or organization. WDP and Pure Promotions may ultimately pay us, but they don't tell us what to do on the field. Implying otherwise is just wrong.
re: Rage and the fight
My field had just finished for lunch on Friday and I sent a couple of refs to help out other fields, so one of my refs was actually among the first guys to jump in to help break up the scuffle. When he told me there was a fight, my first question was "who did Rage beat up?" The only surprise was that they started the crap on Friday; they usually wait until Saturday to start. Personally, I think anyone who left the deadbox should have been kicked out of the event. Letting them keep playing was just plain wrong. Nexus players didn't get involved so there was no reason to boot them. Politics, politics, politics - I can guess who the rules committee member was who wanted to eliminate both Rage and Nexus. Nick is right - the NPPL Disciplinary Committee is a joke.
re: Robbo
I saw you on your way to the back just after the fight and he was already making jokes about it. Glad to hear nothing was seriously busted.
Just so there's no misunderstanding - I applaud your efforts to set up a truly independant reffing body for the sport. I think it's an excellant idea and hope it comes off.
And yes, I've signed the petition