Originally posted by Grendel-Khan
Define what you mean be "Particularly popular", I can't open a magazine without seeing ads from BT or Arakion selling military like guns and addons. There is obviously a market for these somewhere. As for the "military feel" of modern paintball, how many different D-Day games are there in the states? The Desert Fox Game, Tank Wars, Operation Glass Splinter, Blackhawk Down........it's an endless list of real world military storylines played by thousands every month. How does that not qualify as a military feel, if by numbers only? I think there is a fairly large market for military style markers. If these companies are sttaying in business, somebodies buying their products. Whos going to bother with a camo BDu's justs to have a bright red gun?
I didn't say there wasn't a market for it. Be a pretty stupid thing to say really as there quite obviously is. From the guys I met and played with in the US however there was very little evidence of any significant number trying to make their paintball guns emulate real ones... and I met a wide cross section of people from Hells Angels (real ones...) to students from West Point Military Academy who turned up in immaculate white uniforms (they did get changed before play...) even a neuro-surgeon (no rocket scientists tho... )
People who are into guns or just feel that the desire to hurt and kill people overrides their base instinct for survival and hence really wanted to be in the Gulf but couldn't because they were discriminated against by the military for eating too many cheese burgers or having glasses like jam jar bottoms are in the whole (thank god) a minority.
"Particularly popular" by my definition is that in my experience those who are into making their guns look like real ones tend to be in a very small minority when it comes to the overall numbers of people who play paintball.
As regards all the various scenarios you list above, I refer to my earlier comment that they're still just a fantasy... it's more like being in a game or on a movie set and that seems to be the draw for people to play such games. Other than the implied "military" connection due to the title and people dressing up in camo (which I suspect is more just practical if you're playing in the woods than any real desire to be a soldier) there really isn't a "military" feel to any paintball game I've played in this country or in the US.
Until you've actually been involved in a real military action and you realise just how boring they actually are in the majority interspersed with very brief periods of mind numbing stupidity (Hey that guy just shot at me!!! - with real frickin' bullets...") no paintball game is ever going to simulate it... no matter what you call it. Be it "D-Day Derby" or "Gulf War Slaughterfest" it's still nothing more than a "live" version of an X-box game and that's why I say it has no real military feel to it.
If you want a real military feel, go live a muddy, water filled hole in the ground for two weeks with inadequate equipment, cold food, no communication with the outside world taking it in turns with your oppo to stare at nothing for hours on end each day... until someone comes and says "Right guys... we're gonna move 2 miles east, dig some new holes... and do it all again!" ... now there's some REAL military action for ya...
Also note to Rambo wannabees... real bullets don't bounce... and strangely when you wipe the stain keeps coming back...
(Note to Russ... see... not one frickin' smiley in the whole post... you happy now?)