Hmm, agree to a point, but how could you define the criteria?
What yardstick are you going to use to define knowledge experience etc
Post counts are out - look at some of the post counts which go from 1 to a gazillion billion in about a week from posting sh*te.
IQ, excludes front playerz, who may at times have some valuable insight (although I agree the Tweenies & playbus should be off topic).
Experience? means Newbies may have trouble asking questions.
Educational Achievement - everybody knows they suck the common sense out of you at university, so exclude that graduates?
Country of Origin, are we to have quota's for ethnic minorities now? Like sorry we've already got 1000 members from the UK, but we're a little short on the view's of the Lesbian Womens Afghan Refugee X-ball team?
Ahhh, but did I see Fee slipped in there????? Rancid not looking to line one's pockets by chance?
Ok so I'm being an ickle bit facetious, but they are very difficult qualities to define, although prepared to stand corrected.