Isn't the awards thing just a back-slapping piss-up?
If that's what it is, why persevere? Someones going to win, and everyone else is going to be mad and say the whole thing was fixed.
...and here's the thing. If the awards are done right, they go to the same people/organisations every year, because there isn't a new 'best (insert any word)' every year. The same people will be the best. That's why they are the best.
I could see it every 10 years.
I'm gonna disagree with you here. There are very different organisera out there who each do big games, events, mid sized games, etc. Different awards for, say, best big game, best event, best magfed, best location, get the site owners involved for best sites, best welfare.
As exanples off the top of my head you have paintfeat, NvS and Mayhem who all do 'big games', urban do loads of different events, and then you have all the walkon events.
You can then look at the players/teams themselves. Best up and coming/ team, most developed, players choice, etc etc.
There is plenty of scope so it isnt just the same guys on the top table getting awards that makea the pb community feel more involved, as well as getting the shop owners to feel more accountable to their buyers with beat customer service, best on site stall etc.
Lots to work with, just needs a group of guys (and ladies) to want to do it.