I don't think you give people enough credit for understanding basic business practice and managing thier own companies.
What's "enough"? But 'managing their own companies' is pretty general. I'm sure there are plenty of things these guys are very good at, but I don't think managing marketing dollars, including sponsorships, is one of them. A guy who gets products designed, figures out how to get them economically manufactured, and get them distributed, is not necessarily going to be an expert at marketing his business. Colleges charge tens of thousands a year for marketing degrees for a reason.
Think back 10 years about where these companies have invested their sponsor/marketing dollars. They've bought ads in paintball magazines, sponsored paintball teams, and sunk money into unsuccessful television shows. Does this strike you as being a very sophisticated marketing strategy? Do you think these guys have ever sat down and really put together a plan to market the sport to people who don't already play it?
Not only do I not give a lot of credit to these guys on how they spend their sponsor money, I'm fairly well convinced they have no idea what they are doing.
But I have a bit of an unfair advantage - the billion dollar companies that sponsor the NCPA do employ people whose CAREERS are marketing, and seeing what they want has been a very quick lesson in how poor of a job this sport has done at marketing. Everytime I think about how people thought all they had to do was get on TV and everything else would take care of itself I just have to laugh a bit - and not just at others, because I used to think exactly the same thing myself. Now I know better.
From your perspective it is difficult to see what effect (if any) a sponsored Pro team would have on sales for any given firm. From, lets say, Dave Youngbloods perspective, it is easier to monitor and calculate. In my mind, and in this random example, this would make him a better source of accurate information.
I agree that it's difficult to get ROI out of a Pro paintball team, and I think Dave addressed that by getting Ollie Lang instead. But even Ollie Lang is underutilized. Dave bought a young, attractive, extremely popular paintball player.
If I were Dave, I'd cut a Pro team or two, and buy some guest spots for Ollie on some mainstream television shows. Or maybe work some tabloid magic and have him "seen" with some celebrity person. Hell, Dave should hire Ollie a publicist. Would be the best money ever spent in paintball.
As for what Pro teams should do, there are lots of things. They can be as simple as having team posters made and sending them out to all the fields in your area to be posted. Put a link on your website for people to sign up for your team's monthly or quarterly newsletter. Have a fan site where you pick a couple people every event to be on your pit crew. Would you believe some Pro teams get pit crew by posting on a generic paintball web forum? If you were going to be especially bright, you'd make your fans go to your sponsor's website. Or you'd have your sponsor put your team on every gun they sell, and people who buy the gun get a chance to pit for you. Then you're getting your sponsor to pay to brand you!
Then once you've got your brand developed, you need to cash in - out of the industry. Go watch any of the other 'extreme' sports. Those things are not financed by the equipment manufacturers for those sports. There was a brief time in each sport where that's the way it was, but then players got picked up by out-of-industry sponsors.
I have, for example, never been to a skate park. I've never even seen one. Never saw it on TV until I started watching to steal ideas for broadcasting paintball. But I know who Tony Hawk is. You probably know who Tony Hawk is. Why is that?
Did anyone ever stop to think how it is we got to the point where the sales are declining? Isn't that the very definition of a marketing failure? Who is responsible for that failure if not the very same paintball company owners you're suggesting I should believe know what they are doing?
The most famous paintball player on the planet is Greg Hastings. Think about that. Scary, ain't it?