Welcome To P8ntballer.com
The Home Of European Paintball
Sign Up & Join In

After Maxs Masters

Nick Brockdorff

New Member
Jul 9, 2001
588
0
0
www.uglyducklings.dk
Under the rules, an eliminated player cannot get reinstated... and if that happens, the refs are making mistakes.

- Which is the main reason refs need to look around and check if other refs are making contrary calls, before pulling a player.

Nick
 

Wadidiz

EnHaNcE tHa TrAnCe
Jul 9, 2002
1,619
0
0
73
Stockholm, EU
Visit site
Steve Hancock said:
Can someone confirm whether this [If a ref sees a player playing on and that player eliminates an opposition does the opposition get reinstated?] happens or not for me, cheers.
A player who has been marked by an opponent who was already eliminated at the moment of shooting is technically not validly eliminated. Therefore a reffing squad, under the best of circumstances, will not call the invalidly marked player eliminated but will wipe such a player. In practice that is extremely difficult to do every time because it requires a reffing squad that operates very effectively as a team and with near-perfect communication. That also means having more referees on the field than most tournament leagues can afford/desire to pay for.

Another point here is that no re-instating should ever be allowed if that means putting a player back into the game who has clearly been signalled as eliminated. That for obvious reasons.
 

jotajotaZ

New Member
Feb 7, 2003
250
0
0
Spain
www.ninatoz.org
Which in turn means that every time a playing-on player shoots someone out should be awarded a 2x1. I'd even award him a 2x1 for every instance of playing on he engages in (ie two penalties if he shoots two opposing players out)
 

PEBBLE

Toot de la fruit!
Nov 8, 2004
1,352
86
73
.

Kellys got a BS 141 call that cost us the finals (7man that is) on the DYE field

i know it happens but it always seems to happen to us and has happened so many times in the worst possible games its FUBAR we are the unluckiest team in the world or just hated that much my certain REF's

I think PRO refs are the way forward then nobody can blame
"biased-ness"
 

Nick Brockdorff

New Member
Jul 9, 2001
588
0
0
www.uglyducklings.dk
but it always seems to happen to us

If you are good enough, your margin is big enough to sustain the occasional bad call... you rarely see Dynasty or XSV miss a final because of a bad call... and bad calls DO happen in every sport - all the time.

Nick