Welcome To P8ntballer.com
The Home Of European Paintball
Sign Up & Join In

Smartparts ION or WRATH

Lovetone

Peter Pan of Paintball
Feb 25, 2005
4,208
47
73
Manchestoh
www.myspace.com
hope i dont get flamed but, yes these guns are nice (ion i have tried for myself) but for £250 for the gun with fittings and a barrel perhaps id be hard pushed to want one more than say a decent 2nd hand gun off classified - just cos these markers are tried tested and are high quality build specification.
 

bulldog2k

New Member
Originally posted by John C
£500 for a full setup? You can get a really nice tourney setup for that price
Such as the Ion? ;)

John, I'm a huge fan of yours - you've helped me many times in the past and I admire and respect your opinion. Hence, this is not flaming - just friendly debate!

Where does the SP scepticism come from? WDP were just as guilty as SP by pursuing the SP legal approach (ie; own the patent to make the money)

I dont think a spool valve gun is appropriate for a backup gun anyway. Far too many moving orings.
And you'd extend that to freestyle's and trix's too?

From reading how the wrath works I think it will make an excellent starter or backup gun.
For all of us who haven't tried one yet, that's still just speculation though, isn't it - informed speculation, mind :)

The key difference between the two designs will be reliability and the ability to field strip the bolt.
Maybe. Reliability - well, time will tell. With the exception of Size 6 Feet, people seems pretty happy from that point of view. In an entire day of tournament play, I didn't NEED to fieldstrip the bolt on the Ion. And you didn't mention weight ;)

Thing is, I'm not ADVISING anyone to buy anything. I'm just saying I never made a smarter move than 'down-sizing' rfom a Fly ir3 to the Ion, that I couldn't be happier with it, and that I don't need anyone's approval to validate that choice for me.

That's not directed at you at all, John - just at the people who want to be 'approved' of by choosing the 'right' one out of Ion vs Wrath. I don't think there is a 'right' one. Buy whichever you like ;)
 
Originally posted by bulldog2k
Such as the Ion? ;)
Yes, but the ION is supposed to be the budget marker, so I expect the complete setup to be much cheaper.
With the hype it has recieved I expect to be blown away by the price.

Obviously you could get much better value with a preset and a different barrel. But there are some quality guns available on the classifieds for the £400 mark.

Originally posted by bulldog2k

Hence, this is not flaming - just friendly debate!
Dont worry Im pretty much unoffendable. People have tried they really have!!

Originally posted by bulldog2k

Where does the SP scepticism come from? WDP were just as guilty as SP by pursuing the SP legal approach (ie; own the patent to make the money)
Nothing to do with patents. Lets face it they got bitch slapped and made to look silly in the electro gun patent farce, so why would I dislike them for that.

I think they rely on hype and bull**** instead of properly designing their products.

Then you have companies like AGD who use engineering principles and scientific experiments to work out what makes a difference and what doesnt.
But because they dont pay a load of pro teams to use their gear and it doesnt sell nearly as well.

Maybe its not smart parts that I hate, but the mentality of paintballers in general. They take in all the SP hype without question. All it takes with alot of SPs claims is to look at what it actually does, not what they claim. Then you see through the crap straight away.

Originally posted by bulldog2k

And you'd extend that to freestyle's and trix's too?
Yeah.
Anything with that many moving orings doesnt make a great backup gun. I want to be able to grab my backup out of my gear bag after 6 months without needing to strip it and grease it. I wouldnt ever do that with a spool valve.
As a main gun a spool wouldnt be so bad, as you will be cleaning it and lubing it after you play anyway. (well you should be)


Originally posted by bulldog2k

For all of us who haven't tried one yet, that's still just speculation though, isn't it - informed speculation, mind :)
All of this is speculation. No one has used an ion for long enough to pass judgement either.

The Wrath works like a timmy, but instead of the expensive two way air switching noid, it has a one way solenoid and a spring to return the ram.

I really like the idea, its a really clever way of saving money. Maybe thats the only reason I like it.


Originally posted by bulldog2k

Maybe. Reliability - well, time will tell. With the exception of Size 6 Feet, people seems pretty happy from that point of view.
In an entire day of tournament play, I didn't NEED to fieldstrip the bolt on the Ion.
You will need to fieldstrip the bolt one day.
I have airbags on my car. I drive it around trying not to crash and I dont need to use the airbags, but when I do I will be glad of them.



Originally posted by bulldog2k

And you didn't mention weight ;)
Using a 0.8 bottle makes my gun lighter than 90% of tourney setups.

That and the weight of your hopper is a much bigger factor than saving a few ounces on your gat.

I also shoot quite alot of paint, so for me, using an ion is out of the question. Even with the QEV mod my Ir3 blows it out of the water efficiency wise.
In fact my ir3 is far more efficient than the new angels. So even though I own a newer angel I use my '3.


Its a bit early days for the Ion vs Wrath debate, but i think the wrath has the edge because its a tried and tested design with a clever twist. But thats just my opinion.

All I can suggest to people is dont believe the hype and dont believe the opinions of people who are 'paid' to hold a certain opnion.
 

bulldog2k

New Member
actually John, there's a lot I agree with there - damn, you're a tough guy to argue against..!

Using a 0.8 bottle makes my gun lighter than 90% of tourney setups.
I always used a 0.8 baby bottle AIR (with a preset reg) on my iR3, and that then transferred to my Ion. The same set up on my Ion compared to the iR3 = 1 lb 2 oz lighter, which I guess equates to a 6 lb set up rather than a 7? Lighter, yes - significant..? Debate...

That and the weight of your hopper is a much bigger factor than saving a few ounces on your gat.
Well - hmm - a big fat hmm atcha. I agree but, (a) I'm not talking about a few ounces, I'm talking about 18 of them, and (b) which hopper are we talking about? A full egg weighs near as dammit the same as a full reloader anyways... ;) Unless you usually play with 160 balls in an egg with a lot of air space rattlin' round..?
 

Pump'n'Splat

Ambassador of BOING!
Playing devil's advocate..

I think they rely on hype and bull**** instead of properly designing their products.
So how come the Impulse has been such a popular and dependable marker for so long then? They must've been doing something right....

...Oh, and I don't really like SP either, but the Pulse and ION are both markers that've put a big ole smile on my face....