J
Most but not all penalties are not player specific. The point is if a player commits an infraction the team pays for it--unless you are suggesting teams play down a player for one or two games? (In which case your version is more stringent than most Xball penalties.) For minors the penalty time expires if the other team scores.Originally posted by Steve Hancock
I know that time outs are more reminiscent of regular sports, but I always thought that sitting out the next game (or 2 for major penalties) would make more sense in terms of the way x-ball works.
1-- I quite get that part thanks, Chi-town, but I still maintain the offender should be in the box particularly when it's a carry over penalty. Otherwise you not only have refs "randomly" picking players to put in the box you may lose the services of a key player through no action of his own and as such ref discretion opens a narrow window to bias and abuse. And if you charted penalties in the NXL last year I'd be willing to bet there were certain players who pretty much never got put in the box.Originally posted by Chicago
1--There is a reason you put a different player in the penalty box - because that's the LIVE player. You can't put the player who committed the penalty in the penalty box because they are ELIMINATED, and since they've been shot, they shouldn't be coming back into the game when the penalty is over. The player who hasn't been shot should be the one coming back into the game when the penalty is over.
2--This is not so much of an issue as it was in the beginning of XBall though when points still often took longer than 2 minutes, although the penalties should be reduced - 2 and 5 minutes is too long when you're looking at 32 or even 15 minutes of game time. That's a third of the match! Compare that to hockey, with 60 minutes of game time, and major penalties are still 5 minutes - that's only one 12th of the game. And 2's are only one 30th. Even at one minute, a minor penalty is twice as long as a 2 minute penalty in a 15-minute XLite match.