M25 Vendetta??

[sjt19]

This is part of a pm i received from one of the judges from the last M25 tournaments. We were subjected to a bizarre set of decisions on one of the fields and one fo the judges who made one of those decisions sent me this:

QUOTE:

And did you ever wonder what happens when you slag off marshalls? Well now you've found out

END QUOTE

i have erased his name from the bottom, but I do not feel that he should be allowed to judge the next event if his actions and this pm is representative of how he responds to criticism.

When will the 'you slag me off i screw you' mentality end?

Sam

 

[nickp]

probably about the same time as the...


you made a bad call against me team so I'll slag you off on the forums.... on does..


Marshalls should be unbiast in their marshalling if they can not be then they shouldn't be marshalling...

 

[Recoil]

Originally posted by nickp
probably about the same time as the...
you made a bad call against me team so I'll slag you off on the forums.... on does..

Not really the same thing is it....

People moan about marshalling all the time, justified or not.. and if a duff decision is made people will rightfully be angry about it....

however to threaten/gloat at a team/person about marshalling decisions should mean that person no longer marshalls.

SJT19, have you informed the Tourney Organiser about this?

 

[nickp]

Originally posted by Recoil
Not really the same thing is it....

People moan about marshalling all the time, justified or not.. and if a duff decision is made people will rightfully be angry about it....

however to threaten/gloat at a team/person about marshalling decisions should mean that person no longer marshalls.

SJT19, have you informed the Tourney Organiser about this?

I think it is the same thing.. yes from a different side... but very similar any way... if people are not happy with a marshalling decision on a field they should speak to the marshalls on that filed, then the ultimate of the series.. not just flame the marshalls on here.. or any where else...

 

[L J]

Originally posted by sjt19
criticism.

When will the 'you slag me off i screw you' mentality end?

Sam

im trying to understand this...you said the marshalls were crap/untrained or what have you, and then because of this, they penalised your game on field because of soething on the forums? or did u insult a marshall on field, and him penalise you somehow?? if its the first one then thats totally wrong, marshall will never be pefect, and will make mistakes, and the only way to improve is make mistakes an learn from them, which means someone telling you what u did wrong. if its 2, then u deserved it

 

[sjt19]

Originally posted by cockersrule
you said the marshalls were crap/untrained or what have you, and then because of this, they penalised your game on field because of something on the forums

Thats it.

 

[nickp]

Sam

the marshalls have provided you right by penalising you for the comments you made.... if your comments about them where incorrect they would have had no bais when marshalling your team...

 

[Parksy]

Originally posted by nickp
Sam

the marshalls have provided you right by penalising you for the comments you made.... if your comments about them where incorrect they would have had no bais when marshalling your team...

Got to agree there Nick If a marshall is being unbiased he has to base his decisions on events in the game at hand, not previous events on or off the field between players and marshalls, quite unprofesional behaviour in my opinion....

Dave

 

[sjt19]

A few people have pm'd me, and they have all guessed who the person was. Apparently he has a bad reputation with teams who frequent the M25.

 

[nickp]

as recoil said...

has anyone brought it to the attention of the organisers???