Hmm
I dont see how you can say that a return to the woods would be more harm than good for the sport you only have to look back to see while woodsball was about paintball was booming and supair came in with everyone thinking it was good for tv so xball took over .
Whats happened now it has not grown at all and in fact its dying at this stage i would say it would be quite the opposite.
What im getting at is the identity of sup'air in its own right has become ingrained in piantball, to remove it and return to playing in the woods would undo all that work in establishing sup'air paintball, it pushes itself away from the military, war simulation styled games related to woodsball, and offers a more "sporty" style of play. This is what attracts those players (like myself) who dont wish to run around the woods in camo gear etc
This idea that because X-ball, or 7 man is flawed and therefore un repairable is unproductive, this sport is what 25-30 years old? thats half a blink of an eye. Many more developments are on the horizon, Formula 5 is an example of that evolutionary step in sup'air.
Going back to the woods is a not going to push the sport of paintball forward, merely patch a delemma we are current witnessing.
Some players may wish for this, however the sport of paintball, from a sup'air perspective along with an economic one, does not as the current stats show.
If TV will only have a limited value in paintball, and that is a given in this theory, then the only way our sport is to develop is to concentrate on the creation of regional domestic academies and institutions as in other sports. A grass roots player base can be generated through such infrastructures. This current path of the industry leading us in development has seen the commercialisation of paintball in a bid for Television I.e. X-Ball this failed in its attempts, So now we have an expensive format which people are now considering to be the wrong path. The industry needs to generate profit, this is also a given and X-ball does this, but the value for money elements is driving people away from paintball. From my rather naive and utopian perspective it appears that mirroring structures in other sports, gathering that infrastructure would alter paintball dramatically for the better, and we would see something on the lines of Rugby or football in terms of organisation. This would in turn give the validity needed to class paintball as a "sport" officially, and try and get funding elsewhere, the options that would open up to paintball if it was validated as a sport would grow. Also this growth would naturally be profitable to the industry, meaning sponsorships and support packages to those successful teams would be far more valuable, instead of buy "X" amount and we will sponsor you type deals
.
Such institutions such as the Federation is a good starting point, sadly as always its easier said than done, and circumstances in reality seem to get in the way
So I feel going back to woodsball would be another digression in our development.