Why not go both? In the winter wear y-fronts or something similar with long johns
and then over the top a pair of baggy's. this way you have the best of both worlds.
also your balls are safer this way. trust me on this.
summer time tigh pant's or boxers may i add since these days the spandex boxers are out and i've heard are quite comfortable. then baggy's on over the top unless you want to do it superman stylee
i need to stop talking about male underwear