queries

[Big Mac]

no worries dude- bad marshalling, plus it wasnt you it was the guy at the brick who'd already been shot. oh well, you guys still played well, see you next round

not on about your game mate - on about the game with northern storm

 

[KitsuneAndy]

Also the new rule about being shot in the back pack was pathetic,sometimes you don,t feel them,and being 141 for this i feel was unfare.Once rules are set then they should stay that way and not change every new game.

The rule was 100% fair in my opinion. 1-4-1 for playing on if a shot hits a thin part of the pack that the ref judges you could feel the shot through.

It's not about penalising you for 'cheating' it's to address the fact that you had undue influence on a game as you were playing on when you had been eliminated. Even if you didn't feel the hit, you were still eliminated.

We had one bad call against us during the day, not even going to mention which field it was on because it was a geniune mistake, the ref thought it was the right decision at the time and mistakes do sometimes happen. The ref apologised, explained why he'd made the decision the way he did and that was enough for me.

 

[IONfire]

When i asked the ultimate to explain his decision he contradicted hiself twice the decision had been made our last player was put back in and allowed to hang the flag then the other team had a moan to the ultimate and he went back on his decision and let them have the points

So ontop of havin a death in the family on thursday 2 playes not turning up sunday morning and then that costin us 3rd i was very VERY P!SSED off other than that a great day as usual

right i was a player for full on in this game and watch what happened from the dead box as usual and saw my player get checked and no shot was found then your mugger came past and shot him after he had been shot BUT the marshall did not go in and wipe my teams player down he shot your last player who had no paint and then another marshall spotted the shot

also if you want to talk about rules your last player should have been elimated for picking paint off the floor with the intention of shooting it which is an elimanation so that should of meant game over for him

sorry for rant im finished

paddy
full on

 

[no-infernomark]

i agree to disagree, everyone will have different opinions of the said incident, i agree with the pack hit elimination rule sucking, yes i agree your shot, but if you dont feel it how do you know to check yourself? are youe meant to play the whole game chasing your tail checkin? again my opinion. but think all this argument not just the pack hit thing is swings and roundabouts, i can say this you can say that, he can say this and they can say that.

 

[KitsuneAndy]

i agree to disagree, everyone will have different opinions of the said incident, i agree with the pack hit elimination rule sucking, yes i agree your shot, but if you dont feel it how do you know to check yourself? are youe meant to play the whole game chasing your tail checkin? again my opinion. but think all this argument not just the pack hit thing is swings and roundabouts, i can say this you can say that, he can say this and they can say that.

At the captains meeting Wendy said that marshalls would not be 1-4-1ing if the shot hit one of your pots, or the part of the pack that holds the pots as they are the most padded parts and therefore there is a chance that you wouldnt feel it. However, if you were hit on the part of the pack that comes around your waist or over the small of your back then it would be up to the ref to decide whether that part of the pack was thick enough for you to not have felt it or whether you should be 1-4-1'd.

Seemed a sensible way to do it imo.

 

[no-infernomark]

i agree that would be the best option but if some people eliminate you for a hit round the back of the back, then it sort of defeats the object of implementing the rule. rules should be abided by all not some pull you for something and others dont, people watch games and do get the feel for what they can and cant do.

 

[KitsuneAndy]

i agree that would be the best option but if some people eliminate you for a hit round the back of the back, then it sort of defeats the object of implementing the rule. rules should be abided by all not some pull you for something and others dont, people watch games and do get the feel for what they can and cant do.

You should be eliminated for a hit anywhere

I think you mean 1-4-1'd

But yes, reffing should be consistant no matter what field you were on.

But tbh, I thought the reffing on Sunday was fine, especially as not all the marshalls made it on the day.

 

[no-infernomark]

i cant comment on the marshalling as wasn't there was just my general opinion of it all, and yes i do mean 141'd sleep deprivation gettng the better of me

 

[dazafox]

pack shot

My captain was playing when a marshal came over to him and said,you have been hit in your back pack ,so he was 141 then the marshal proceeded to take one of our live players,as he was doing this that player was hit ,so the marshal came to me and said you have been shot in the stomach baffled i showed him my front and was very confused,then he said im pulling you out on a 141,which i then understood.I think some marshals need to be a bit more switched on.

 

[graeme_b]

Technically if he'd called you clean, then yeah you're clean and free to play, from what i've heard it was the tiniest bit of paint. At the end of day you always get some good and bad calls against you, it'll all average itself out!

And Craig your captain went about it in the wrong way!!! Sorry but just my point of view