1--Mark, you're outta the loop, my brotha, if you will re-read my original number 3 perhaps it will sink in. Disney was originally pursued with the intention of showcasing a NPPL/PSP style event finals. Not X-Ball. Now, after the IAO and Nations Cup the whole WC schedule is changed and Sunday at Disney is now an X-Ball exhibition.Originally posted by Mark
1--Ok Baca whilst I can agree with your #1 answer and sorta #2 though don't think it is bandwagon jumping as you and I well know Disney was well in the pipeline long before X ball (outside pressures may have been applied once the success of X ball was predicted, plus an endevour to sooth any discomfort felt with the PSP NPPL split) but anyhow.
2--Your #2 look at the schedule at the begining of this thread Am's don't play anyone but themselves so it only leaves the Novice, the Rookies and the Pro's so unless the Rookies are gonna play against themselves the Divisions will be Pro, Novice and Rookie hence the "ideal world" list I posted for order of play due to ability
Not a great idea to face a Pro team as a Rookie or even as a Novice, (not saying you should never try and play a little harder and try to elevate your skills etc) The Am tourny (10 man is all over when the prelims start for the rest) so who is left to get hammered?? Plus I have read on places like pbnation (when the damned server wasn't crashing !!) that the Am's feel cheated out of a tourny (actually it is younger players bitching about having to miss school mainly, but then I will be there for the week before the tourny and for a couple of days after so it doesn't effect me, but does seem a little silly not to take the whole week as holiday...hey it is sunny Florida) I am in the situation of having to play teams above my rating ...personally I don't care but then for the "big picture" it needs to be raised that it appears unfair.
2--the way any other NPPL/PSP event would have been run and has been run in four other events to date this year is this: Prelims--Pro plays (usually) three other Pros and a 2/3 mix of Ams and Novs (usually). Am plays one Pro in prelims with other 7 games a mix of Am and Nov. Novs play one Pro, one Am, one (or sometimes two) Rookies, the rest other Novs. Rookies play a mix of Nov and Rookie. All they are going to do is jury rig some similar schedule minus the Ams.
With the changes made to accomodate X-Ball exhibition 5-man is beginning play on Sunday instead of Monday. Ams are playing 10-man as a stand alone on Tues. & Wed. instead of Friday, Saturday and Sunday and are then being asked to ref everyone else. The 10-man prelims if this schedule holds will be designed as usual but leave Ams out which means Novs still play one Pro and what would have been an Am game will probably now be another Nov or extra Rookie game.
What the Ams and any one else who is unhappy has a real problem with is late change of dates as WC typically attracts twice the number of teams as any other event and many teams make their travel arrangements well in advance to get cheaper plane tickets for example. That and school schedules are going to hurt the Ams and numerous Novs and Rookies and the only reason any of this is being done is to accomodate an X-Ball Sunday that nobody was comtemplating prior to IAO.
Tony--quit using your product, dude.
Any teams that regularly play the NPPL know exactly what they're getting and that's the problem. This time they ain't. WC normally would have expected around 150 Nov/Rookie 10-mans showing. Those that sign to play Rookie are doing so to AVOID playing the "big boys" and the Novs get one of each, Pro and Am (normally). Truth is half the Novs or more don't belong either in terms of their ability to actually be competitive with the top Novs much less the "big boys."