My you're nice.
His question didn't refer to what length barrel to use, it was peoples opinions if a freak was better than a boomstick.
My opinion also still stands, these days you can get a range of length barrels to fit all situations so length of barrel does not come into it, if you want a 12" barrel you can get boomstick or freaks of that length, if you want a 16" barrel you can also get boomsticks or freaks in that length.
As suicide didn't say what position he played your rude reply made no sense.