Tell you what Robbo, those players sound like an awesome combination - you should try and get them all together on a team - they'd be the next best thing I reckon!
As for my views:
Front: Tommy Pimplebum (of ex-Bugout fame
{ok, so he might be known for playing with some nexus type team now, I dunno)
Mid: Nick Truter (OK, I know this is kinda out of position according to what everyone else has said, but whenever I saw the Rushers play they were away and up the field in no time, so their backs became mids very quickly
)
Back: Bozza from Tigers, or Jimmy the Sponge, or Ledz