The soft one is good, but not 100% keeping in paint, but its still better than a speed feed, the standard wont lose paint when you use the collar, there is no front player crown as some will say losing paint is bad and so get a standard, some will say fast loading is key and get the soft, same with back players, though i think because some players dont move much, the soft would be good as they need to refill fast. I would get the soft as its really good and still better than a speed feed IMO