Didn't say it was perfect...just an idea that can have a benifit.
unless a major redsign takes place (Egg III) the current Egg will never be a force feeder whatever paddle/software is installed. Incidently it is americans who are doing the old paddle swap not english so you might be very surprised to how many people are doing this as you can't tell by watching someone play. The Halo has hard plastic guides and they don't smash paint all the time, if they were to change the the impellor disc to a soft rubberised material like the EggII paddles then the balls would bounce all over the place. All designs are a compromise.